Ayman Hamed was a America-based member of Hizb ut-Tahrir who had previously served on the American Majlis during Fawzy’s period of national responsibility. He was not a newcomer unfamiliar with the administrative files or the expectations attached to a national council position. His older brother, Abu Haitham, had previously served as the American Mu’tamid. Those relationships placed Ayman close to former national leadership and made his subsequent conduct more consequential than an isolated disagreement among ordinary members.
The disciplinary issue preceded the July candidate meeting. The internal record includes a complaint that had already been filed on June 16 and a second written complaint from Hatib Umar dated June 25 concerning Ayman’s statements at a South Chicago gathering on June 23. Hatib wrote that Ayman had criticized the sitting Majlis before assembled members, urged them to participate so they would not repeat the previous election’s outcome, and cast suspicion on why the Amir had called an election. Hatib described the remarks as part of a longer pattern and warned that using an election meeting to attack particular officials was damaging the organization’s internal cohesion. The 2022 election-process document had itself included a special warning against speaking about sitting council members or nominees during the contest and instructed members to report such activity to the Amir, making Hatib’s complaint recognizable within the organization’s own prior election standards.
The dispute also intersected with an existing disciplinary rule. On June 28, Fawzy circulated a notice attributed to the General Manager that people punished above the level of Tanbeeh, or caution, during the previous term could not stand for the Electoral Body in the new term. In the notice, Ayman was listed as having received an Inzar Nihai (final warning, an internal disciplinary notice; under Hizb ut-Tahrir’s administrative rules, a warning remains in effect for six months, and continued negligence can be referred to the Amir for further action), and Ashraf was listed as having received an Inzar, or warning. Fawzy informed the council that those punishments barred them from standing for that Electoral Body election. That restriction concerned eligibility to run; a separate directive the next day addressed Ayman’s participation more broadly.
By June 29, Ayman had received the further instruction. The urgent message addressed to the South Naqib said that two serious complaints had been filed and that, pending a general manager’s decision, Ayman was suspended from Hizb activities and had:
“No involvement in elections in any capacity.”
Fawzy indicated that the instruction was also sent to the election committee. The breadth of the directive matters. It did not merely forbid Ayman from running for one particular office or recommending another candidate. It took him out of election activity altogether while the complaint was pending.
The July 1 Chicago candidate meeting nevertheless put Ayman back into the election. In his July 5 written complaint to the Amir, Hatib described a candidate gathering organized under the Mandub’s direction and alleged that the 2025 delegate had permitted group campaigning and an organized meeting by the Ajhizah. Hatib identified Ayman as a speaker despite the earlier disciplinary record. This was not simply a private conversation between friends: according to the complaint, the issue was the use of an organized election setting and its authority to advance particular nominees.
The contradiction was discussed inside the sitting Majlis as events developed. Irfan asked:
“How is Ayman in this list?”
Fawzy replied that the council would discuss it and that an investigation was still pending. The member who had been expressly barred from participating was again visible in the election process.
The most revealing evidence connecting Ayman to Abu Amr came from Ayman's own written explanation. Ayman had been explicitly ordered to stay out of the election, yet complaints placed him at the center of a July 1 Chicago effort to promote five candidates as a group. When confronted, Ayman explained in writing that he had acted because Abu Amr instructed him to do so, and Fawzy presented that response to the full sitting Majlis. The significance was unmistakable: the election official responsible for enforcing the rules was identified by Ayman as the very person who directed him to participate despite the prohibition, raising serious questions about both men's conduct and their respect for the organization's own rules.
Shirazi also described a personal visit from Ayman during which, according to Shirazi, he was urged to support selected names aligned with Abu Amr's preferred direction. That separate account gave the sitting Majlis another reason to examine how the organized Chicago campaign operated.
Leadership ultimately removed Ayman from the Majlis contest, but the candidates associated with the effort remained. Removing the visible organizer did not reverse whatever advantage the organized campaigning had already created.
Qusay Froukh supplied a separate Chicago account. He described knowing about the campaign effort, expecting to be included, and considering a complaint before local members approached him and the immediate dispute subsided. According to the existing witness account, he later regretted not raising the matter when he saw how other local disputes and resignations unfolded. That account should be assessed alongside the original statement before any identification of the person who warned him is treated as independently verified.
The significance of Ayman’s role was also institutional. He was a former Majlis member with a family connection to a former Mu’tamid, familiar with both the rules and the structure administering the election. The June 29 instruction, the July campaign activity, and the later private “majlis” group make his involvement central to understanding how the Chicago dispute developed.