In August 2022, Ashraf warned American election participants that campaigning for other nominees would create a favored list and eventually a subgroup inside Hizb ut-Tahrir. In July 2025, his name appeared inside a private WhatsApp group called “majlis” alongside Ayman, former national council members, and the former American Mu’tamid Abu Haitham. The contrast was extraordinary: the official who had warned members against private electoral blocs was present in a group that Shirazi described as a vehicle for coordinating support for selected candidates. The 2022 warning had been delivered openly to the election participants. The 2025 group came to light because, on July 8, Shirazi was unexpectedly added to it, saw two deleted-message notices and Sajid leave, and then was removed. The private group was not the national election room Fawzy had proposed; it was a separate gathering of people close to the election being contested.
A screenshot of the group information page lists nine members at the moment it was captured. The account labels show “Abdur Rafey” (referred to in this article as Abdu Rafy), Ahmad, Ashraf, Asim, Awais, Ayman, Azeem, Sadiq, and an administrator whom Shirazi identifies as Abu Haitham, Ayman’s older brother and a former American Mu’tamid. The administrator’s displayed nickname is preserved in the original screenshot. A separate chat screenshot records that Sajid had also been in the group and then left. Asim, Azeem, and Sajid had formerly served on the American Majlis. The memberships of Awais and Sadiq, beyond their displayed accounts, still require further background reporting.
The screenshot with the July 8 date shows Abu Haitham adding Shirazi to the group, two messages marked deleted, Sajid leaving, and Abu Haitham removing Shirazi. Shirazi says he was never part of the inner circle and was added inadvertently. He describes a strained relationship with Abu Haitham and says the removal came once the administrator realized who had entered. The sequence of entry, deleted-message notices, Sajid’s departure, and removal is visible. The contents of the deleted messages and the private reasons for each action are not.
The people in that group were not unfamiliar with the organization’s election rules. Abu Haitham had administered the American branch as Mu’tamid. Asim, Azeem, and Sajid had national council experience. Ashraf had personally acted as the 2022 election delegate and warned against campaigning for another nominee. Ayman had previously sat on Fawzy’s Majlis and, by June 29, had been specifically barred from election involvement. The significance of the names lies in the knowledge and influence they brought into the same private room while the 2025 vote was under way.
Ashraf’s presence is especially revealing as a comparison. On August 19, 2022, he explained that candidates should speak only for themselves and that helping other candidates could create a favored list and a subgroup. His warning was clear enough to be used as instruction to the entire Electoral Committee. Three years later, his name appears on the membership screen of a group that Shirazi says was created for precisely the kind of coordination Ashraf had warned members against. The membership screen establishes his presence; Shirazi’s testimony addresses the group’s alleged purpose. That distinction does not erase the contradiction in the standards Ashraf had once insisted upon.
The episode also mirrored a pattern of authoritarian politics that Hizb ut-Tahrir regularly denounces outside its own ranks: influential insiders meeting beyond the view of ordinary participants, a narrow circle holding information about a contested leadership process, and an unintended observer abruptly excluded. Shirazi described the group as an effort to coordinate support for selected candidates, while the screenshots document the membership list, the deleted-message notices, and his removal. The issue was not that every private conversation constitutes wrongdoing. It was the spectacle of experienced officials linked to a disputed election operating inside a restricted circle after the organization had explicitly warned that such electoral blocs could become a subgroup. The same movement that criticizes unaccountable rulers was now confronting questions about secrecy, loyalty, and access to power within its own leadership contest.
The screenshot record also needs to be read against Ashraf’s disciplinary history. A Majlis exchange shared by Fawzy identifies a warning, or Inzar, issued to Ashraf in August 2024. When Fawzy raised the 2025 rule barring previously punished members from standing for the Electoral Body, Ashraf disputed how the punishment should be characterized and questioned whether that instruction had come through the elections Mandub. These messages show that Ashraf knew the disciplinary issue was being raised against his eligibility. They do not, by themselves, establish the content of every private conversation he later had in the WhatsApp group.
Shirazi’s account connects the group to a separate personal encounter. He said Ayman visited him during the election and tried to persuade him to support specific candidates whom Shirazi associated with Abu Amr’s preferred direction. That contact matters because Ayman appears both in a direct attempt to influence a voter and in the July 8 private group. Ashraf appears both in the contemporaneous Chicago dispute and on the group’s membership list. Former senior officials appear alongside them at a moment when the candidate field was already settled and the election was active.
The screenshots do not preserve each participant’s messages or prove that every listed person made a recommendation. They do show the existence of the private group, its visible membership, its date, and how abruptly an unintended member was removed. Shirazi’s account adds why he says the group existed. Considered alongside the 2022 warnings, the June 29 prohibition on Ayman, the July candidate meeting, and the separate voter contact, the group becomes a focal point of the question the article asks throughout: how did experienced officials understand the same election rules in one cycle and operate so differently in the next?
It was a private group with the name of the office being contested. It was called “majlis.” And Shirazi says he was never meant to be inside it.