By the time the election moved toward final approval, complaints had reached the American leadership from Washington, D.C., New York, Los Angeles, Dallas, and Chicago. The details varied, but they no longer looked isolated when placed together.
Dallas had the double vote and the reversal of its authorized rerun. Chicago had Ayman’s prohibited involvement, the five-name campaign effort, and the late withdrawals. Diwan had been accepted and then removed. Other complaints concerned candidate treatment, election communications, and the administration of the Electoral Body.
One of the clearest written challenges was Hatib Umar’s July 5, 2025 complaint to the Amir concerning a July 1 candidate meeting in Chicago, where he reported that the election delegate permitted candidates to campaign for one another and allowed party committees to organize a group campaign event. Hatib contrasted this with Article 14 and the 2022 election, when Ashraf Nusairat had explicitly prohibited candidates from promoting anyone other than themselves and warned against group campaigning. He also objected to statements by Qusay Froukh criticizing the sitting administration and by Ayman Hamed suggesting that reconciliation was needed among members, arguing that these remarks unfairly targeted the outgoing Majlis.
Fawzy received the complaints as Mu’tamid and placed them before the sitting Majlis. The five council members could therefore compare the localities in a way ordinary members could not. What one city experienced as a local controversy appeared to the national council as part of a broader pattern.
That distinction is important. Members in Dallas did not initially know the full Chicago story. Qusay Froukh did not initially know what had happened in Dallas. Electoral Body members did not have one national room in which they could compare how the rules were being applied. The sitting Majlis did.
One internal message summarized the council’s growing conclusion:
“The complaints were being ignored as the corrupted election process moved forward at full speed.”
The council was not demanding that every complaint be accepted. It was demanding that the organization stop long enough to answer them before it declared the election legitimate.
The rules themselves required objections to be addressed before final approval. Instead, the election continued while the complaints remained unresolved.
The 2022 election calendar made this sequence plain: objections were to be considered and settled before final results. The 2025 complaint record shows the same concept under strain. Fawzy told the sitting council that earlier complaints against Ayman remained unanswered even as election activity continued. Members were not asking the organization to invent a review procedure. They were asking it to use one it had already taught them to expect.
That failure pushed the dispute upward—to the channel through which Fawzy was supposed to reach the Amir.